Bruster`s Real Ice Cream in Middletown

Great ice cream and great service!

Oh Wow, what great had made, hand dipped ice cream. The Best !!!

Lot of good options for ice cream and shakes. I just don’t know if all their ice creams are eggless.Update:Owner just responded stating all ice creams are eggless except ones like Oreos. It was nice to get the feedback from the owner. Changing to 5 star. Will be going there more now. Thank you

Great place, good staff, and always fun.

I went to Bruster's because I receive a text message whenever they have coffee ice cream. So my husband ordered a coffee milkshake with caramel syrup and instead of using the regular coffee ice cream they used coffee chocolate chip. The milkshake tasted more like milk than anything. I ordered a blast with coffee ice cream with heath bar and hot fudge mixed in. I don't believe there was any hot chocolate mixed in and the heath bar was not completely mixed in and when I was finally given the cup the ice cream had already melted considerably. I wasn't really happy with this experience.

Awesome Ice Cream treat 4 wife's birthday!

Great Shakes

Great icecream.

Use to live by Buster's icecream so when ever I'm in town by one I stop. Icecream and motorcycle riding go hand and hand.

Everything tasted so fresh and was literally the best ice cream I have ever had. And the prices weren't bad at all either. I loved the sitting area and the whole feel of the place in general. I will definitely be coming back. It's worth the drive.

Ice cream is good, but always seems to be a shortage of the flavors you want.

Nice young man provided a warm smile + great customer service! The ice cream was yummy, too. 😁

Ice cream is awesome, the only issue is that most of the time you have to wait a while. They need more employee's

Great ice cream a little pricey

Great place for great ice cream

I came here last week. The drive thru line was kinda long considering the walk up service is on hiatus due to COVID but it was fast and efficient. The hot fudge brownie sundae was so good! The brownie and hot fudge were all nice hot and fresh, and I love my brownie sundaes! Will be back again!

The owners and employees are friendly and the ice cream is delicious!

I called and asked how much was a single dip cone and was told it was three something. I think that is a lot of money to spend on a small ice cream cone. Then when I went there because I thought I would try it, I told them what flavor I wanted and they asked a waffle cone and I said sure. Well the price of that ice cream cone was over $4. I think it's a little too high because for $4 or even less you could go into a market and get a gallon of ice cream. This is just my opinion and I probably ever get back to Bruster's again.

Great service and delicious ice cream !

Great ice cream!

Service was very good.

The ice cream proportions are huge which is great. The workers are polite and friendly. Very professional.The flavors are on point. Only one complaint I have is the the butter pecan ice cream the pecans are VERY SALTY. That’s the only complaint.

Real ice cream and family owned!

Great family place for ice cream. Staff was friendly and courteous. Love the ice cream flavors, and great price. Drive through always open.

3-Stars is given because All three of the employees on Night Duty were not wearing any Gloves while making/handling the Waffle Cones and serving the Ice Cream. I ordered Caramelized Apple Crunch Ice Cream and it is DELISH.

Love stopping here for ice cream for the family

Delicious ice cream!

Great service, good ice cream. They have a little area for the kids as well.

Great ice cream! They have tons of options- cones, sandwiches, pies, cakes, Italian ices, you name it. They even have a drive thru. Super friendly and fast service, and free pup cups if you've got a dog! Looking forward to trying other flavors in the future when I'm traveling through the area. Worth going out of your way if you need a cool summer treat!

Yummy smooth fresh ice cream. Try the salted caramel flavor. You won't be disappointed!!!!

Birthday cake ice cream is the best!

Great service and quite patient while we perused the menu in the drive thru!

Everyone that works here is always so friendly. Love the cherry vanilla!!!!

Great ice cream and spectacular service!

Good place for ice cream. Portions are large.

Love their ice cream! Server was extremely nice and professional.

I tried the coconut milk strawberry ice cream for the first time today. It was delicious! I had rainbow sprinkles as well. Next time I'll try the vegan cookies and cream flavor.

The ice cream tasted horrendous. I got a strawberry and it was plain, acidic and straight up horrible. Tasted like expired cream cheese.

We love their ice cream. Don't expect small cones (unless you get the baby cone). Great ice cream that normally has great mix-ins and/or flavors.Flavors change constantly, so always a reason to stop back by to try something new or old.

Great day for ice cream 😁

This is a great stop and I strongly recommend! Who doesn't like good ice cream? It's pretty straightforward go there to get good service and great ice cream. It's a nice place to go with a few friends!

Good people Good ice creams, we got our Christmas tree from there parking lot the guy was very funny & helpfull he had better trees then lows or home depot

Always a nice treat, fun place for the family, plus they give us plastic drip guards

Excellent service and with a cheerful attitude too . Good work ladies

What is there not to like about Bruster's Ice Cream? On this visit I enjoyed a blast of vanilla ice cream with Oreos and Butterfingers, and it was absolutely refreshing and delicious. Others in our group enjoyed a variety of hand dipped ice cream cones which also looked enticing. On a hot day like today, many customers come to enjoy the treats, but the staff handles the rush with speed and precision. The benches are good seats before and after your ice cream arrives

Creamy delicious ice cream with unique flavors along with the usual. Have had many of them, no wrong pick!

A little expensive but well worth it. They give you a lot of ice cream for the price and the flavors are so delicious. I love their mint chocolate chip in a waffle cone, add sprinkles. Yummy!

OMG they cookies and cream Ice Cream was so delicious I was upset when it was all gone. I will definitely be traveling back up to Middletown to try out more flavors throughout the summer. Best ice cream I had in a long time

Always the best

Ice cream is good, but servings are small for the costs